Thursday, January 17, 2013

According to Fox News Discussing White Privilege with High School Students is Apparently "Indoctrination" and "Anti-White"

At least they didn't quote Brother Doctor Martin Luther King Jr. out of context.

Schools are one of the primary places where political socialization takes place in a given society. They are indoctrination centers that reproduce the values of a culture. Most folks do not want to think of "education" in that way.

In "post racial" America this poses a dilemma: do you teach young people the truth about this country's history and the semi-permanence of the colorline? As an educator, do you discuss how American society is structured hierarchically and where race, class, and gender over-determine life outcomes?

It would seem that if you are a teacher at Delavan-Darien High School in Wisconsin, you should not dare to broach such questions.

Over the last few decades, there has been an Orwellian turn in American education. It extends from grade school to the university level.

What counts as educational content is being dictated by the logic of the capitalist marketplace, teachers are being subjected to onerous surveillance and harassment, intellectual freedom is being made subject to the political aims of outside actors, and the value of teachers is being undermined by destroying public unions, eliminating tenure, and forcing college professors into a permanent contingent labor force.

In total, the response to Delavan-Darien High School's course "American Diversity" is indicative of the impact of hyper-conservatism on public schools. Ultimately, the students (and by extension all of us) lose because they are not being given the critical thinking tools to be active, reflective, and engaged citizens.

Ideally, any controversy over teaching students about an obvious fact--such as how "race matters" in American society--should be dismissed as silliness.

However, conservatives are prone to authoritarian thinking and a binary worldview that is highly resistant to change and new information. Any critique of their personal mythologies--such as the idea that America is a true meritocracy--is bound to cause howls of complaint, and cries of "indoctrination." When personal mythologies intersect with self-serving narratives about colorblindness, Whiteness and Conservatism cannot help but to overreact in the form of a manufactured crisis.

The Fox News story about Delavan-Darien High School's discussion of White Privilege is also a rich object lesson in the magical thinking and anti-intellectualism which has infected the Right, and America's public discourse, more generally, since the Culture Wars of the 1990s (and which reached a fever pitch with the election of President Obama in 2008 through to the present).

Conservatives have repeatedly complained about the nefarious field of "anti-white" scholarship known as Critical Race Theory. However, they cannot define its range of study. Nor, have those on the Right likely done any vigorous research about its intellectual terrain or scope.

Moreover, there is a deep suspicion of the Academy and "intellectuals" by those on the populist Right. Hostility to Critical Race Theory is really about an unwillingness to discuss racial inequality coupled with a disdain for any type of trained expertise in matters of the mind or intellect.

The ability of outside agitators such as the Tea Party, Young America's Foundation, David Horowitz, and the Koch Brothers to monitor educational content, to bully and harass teachers and professors with whom they disagree, and to interject their "learning materials" into classrooms, is part of a decades-long project  to remake education (on every level) in the service of a neoliberal, far-Right agenda.

The lie of false equivalency, where all sides of an argument are considered legitimate and of equal merit, is a product of a corporate news media entertainment complex that has rejected any responsibility for truth-telling.

For example, Fox News is a professional outlet for distorted information that is legitimated under the guise of being "fair and balanced." The other news networks reinforce the fact free universe of the Right by engaging Fox News' willful distortions of reality as truths.

The lie of false equivalency has been disseminated down to the public as a type of common sense. In turn, this has hamstrung the American people's capacity to engage in critical thought on matters of public concern:
Superintendent Robert Crist says there is merit to parental concern. 
“A lot of red flags go up in my mind when I look at the materials," Crist told Fox News. "Ideally, you would want to present one theory that might be way on the left and another theory that may be way on the right and if you find one in the middle you can present that too … now you have a well-rounded discussion, in my opinion."
There is a priceless irony when complaints about discussing the reality of White Privilege demonstrate the very fact that said concept is both true, and an accurate description of social reality. Whiteness is universalized and normalized in the complaints about Delavan-Darien High School's course on diversity in America.

Could it be that there are students of color who do not share these objections? Alternatively, could there be white students who are benefiting from an active discussion of the relationship between race and privilege in this society?

The language of "white guilt" and "oppression" is itself a reflection of the power held by the white racial frame, where any critical discussion of racial inequality is seen as "racist." Because Whiteness must always be  normalized and protected in American society, discussions of White Privilege are immediately recast as unfair to white folks or a means to practice "reverse discrimination."

The beating heart of the White Right's complaints about discussing White Privilege is a sincere belief that white people are oppressed or somehow disadvantaged in post civil rights America. Such attitudes do the work of polite white racism and day-to-day white supremacy.

Polite white racism in the Age of Obama works through an inability by some to connect the realities of structural inequality with individual life stories. For example:
“This teacher has free reign to pick the material that he wanted to use,” she said. “He chose extremely radical left thinkers. He didn’t give those kids alternative information.”
The parent said last summer her son got a job washing dishes – working sometimes 10 hours a day. 
“I was so proud of him,” she said. “And then to have a teacher tell you that you have these unearned privileges – that because you are white somehow you infringe on other people’s rights. It’s really just awful.”
Sometimes you can't make this stuff up. White Privilege does not exist because a white mother's son got a job washing dishes over the summer. The House that Race Built, and centuries of social and political inequality are quite literally washed away, because a white teenager got a job as a dishwasher?


His mother probably believes such a thing. I hope he knows better. 


Bored at Work said...

I hate the word "post-racial." It's untrue. Have you ever taken that shill, Toure, to task?

chaunceydevega said...

@Bored. Toure is cool folks in the bigger picture. There is lots of stuff in the ether that like minds often pick up on.

Anonymous said...

Wisconsin, my other favorite third world country. Mr. Devega, a closer look at the political structure, and race relations in Wisconsin, will make it very easy to understand the events you are writing about, and the equation of a white suburban mother in Wisconsin, to her son washing dishes ten hours per day, and misunderstanding what white privilege really is.

Bored at Work said...


I dunno. I felt very embarrassed for Toure and Goldie Taylor (?) when they had to be the amen chorus for Lawrence O'Donnell as he said he "regretted the death of Breitbart" on his MSNBC show. It seem ed they felt submissive to him and his questionable sentiment. Toure's appearances on Bill Maher's exploitation-politics show also left me underwhelmed.

Cavoyo said...

“A lot of red flags go up in my mind when I look at the materials," Crist told Fox News. "Ideally, you would want to present one theory that might be way on the left and another theory that may be way on the right and if you find one in the middle you can present that too … now you have a well-rounded discussion, in my opinion."

OK let's see how that would work. After introducing race as a concept invented by Europeans so they could dominate the rest of the world, a concept which determined and determines one's wealth, the school could also present the "right wing" perspective. This says that people of color are incapable of improving their lot because they are genetically lazy and stupid. There's also the moderate right version of this argument, which replaces "genetically" with "culturally." They could then present the moderate perspective, which claims that we live in a post-racial colorblind era despite all evidence to the contrary, and that the best way to approach racism is like the Three Wise Monkeys.

Boy, I would just love to see schoolchildren debate these arguments. I'm sure it would never lead to any resentment between people of different races in the classroom it took place in.

d. said...

Do people really think white kids are this fragile? I appreciated my teachers talking about race issues and we had some brutal classroom discussions about this kind of thing in school. Somehow it didn't shatter our fragile minds to be told that someone can have a dishwashing job and "work so hard" but still have the advantages of whiteness. Some kids obviously didn't open their minds and were angered by the discussion, but it hardly damaged them to be exposed to the concept of their own privilege.

The Fox News handwringing is basically the bigotry of low expectations, for white kids.

Anonymous said...

I blog frequently and I genuinely appreciate your information. This great article has really peaked my interest. I will take a note of your site and keep checking for new information about once a week. I opted in for your RSS feed too.

Anonymous said...

As a result feeling see how to avoid to the fact that [url=]skin care products[/url] you can find them at retailers for example Sephora or Macy's. anti wrinkle cream Herbal tea woods essential oil can also be successful on other epidermis ailments such as ointment joined with Peppermint and British perfect.

Anonymous said...

Properly, to start with, as a way to buy the Nu-Derm Method you must have a health professional prescribed - obagi and negatives from the item you are interested in. obagi products Even if you are not an backyard woman, pander face look far more beautiful and this would expand with your face also.

Anonymous said...

Streamer Pony O's are Bucks5 and Bow - cheer bows excellent morning! how to make hair bows Zebra Daisy to twist, the dark bows waves more quickly.